Deriving Some Properties of Protasis-Referring Conditionals
نویسندگان
چکیده
In §1, I will show that the protasis-referring reading has a number of unusual properties which are not present under other readings of the conditional. In §2, I will present the classic type of analysis for these conditionals, what I term the MOVEMENT ANALYSES. Under these analyses, the if -clause is at some point an argument of the verb. I will show that movement analyses do not adequately account for the unusual properties associated with the protasis-referring reading. In §3, I will introduce a second type of analysis, which I term the QUANTIFICATIONAL ANALYSIS. Under a quantificational analysis, the if -clause functions as the restrictor of a tripartite quantificational structure. The pronoun sits within the nuclear scope, and is bound by the adverbial of quantification.
منابع مشابه
Subjectivity and Intersubjectivity in Conditionals: Temporal Backshifting Strategies in Brazilian Portuguese
• ABSTRACT: This work takes a Cognitive Linguistics perspective on Brazilian Portuguese conditional constructions. Based on mental spaces theory (FAUCONNIER, 1994, 1997; FAUCONNIER; SWEETSER, 1996) and on mental spaces work on conditionals (SWEETSER, 1990; DANCYGIER, 1998, DANCYGIER; SWEETSER, 2005; GOMES, 2008), the research relied on recent contributions on subjectivity and intersubjectivity ...
متن کاملOn Indicative Conditionals
In this paper we present a new approach to evaluate indicative conditionals with respect to some background information specified by a logic program. Because the weak completion of a logic program admits a least model under the three-valued Lukasiewicz semantics and this semantics has been successfully applied to other human reasoning tasks, conditionals are evaluated under these least L-models...
متن کاملWhat can synchronic gradience tell us about reanalysis
This paper discusses verb-first conditionals (Had I known this, I would have stayed at home) with regard to the hypothesis that the construction developed from a dialogual sequence into a hypotactic structure. While plausible, independent evidence for this scenario has been scarce. An alternative account posits that questions could have been analogized with existing conditional clause types, ma...
متن کاملOn the Licensing of Argument Conditionals
Constructions where the clause introduced by wenn 'if' can have a double function in that it is an adverbial that provides the protasis of an implication as well as the propositional argument of a matrix predicate (argument conditionals). Unlike, for instance, Pesetsky's (1991) and Hinterwimmer's (2003) approaches which regard the conjunctions if or when as an "instruction" for the adverbial cl...
متن کاملWondering What Might Be
This paper explores the possibility of supplementing the suppositional view of indicative conditionals with a corresponding view of epistemic modals. The most striking feature of the suppositional view consists in its claim that indicative conditionals are to be evaluated by conditional probabilities. On the basis of a natural link between indicative conditionals and epistemic modals, a corresp...
متن کامل